Peer Reviewer Draft Guidelines

Draft Peer Review Guidelines

We are eager to have your input on the draft Guidelines for Reviewing the Grade-Level Reading Community Self-Assessment that will used by community-nominated peer reviewers to identify 2017 All-America City Award semi-finalists.

Questions to consider: 1) Are the draft Peer Review Guidelines clear and user-friendly? 2) What additional information would be helpful?

Please submit your feedback by January 20 by commenting on the discussion or emailing it to me at

We have sought to make the instructions streamlined and appropriately detailed. Thank you in advance for your always thoughtful review and comments. Download the Review Guidelines by clicking here.